|
Your use of this website is subject to the terms, conditions,
and understandings detailed
here. By accessing this website, you
hereby acknowledge that you have read and accept all of our terms,
conditions, and understandings. |
|
Obedience
Training:
NOTHING can be more rewarding than you and your dog going once a week for a few
hours to obedience training. Learning together as a team will create a
stronger relationship, a closer bond, and enduring loyalty. If you've never
taken a dog through training, we promise you it will be one of the most
rewarding experiences you'll ever have with your dog. Can it be
trying? You bet! Can it be frustrating? Yes. Will your dog
embarrass you? Count on it! But the pay off is, not only will your
dog learn from this, but YOU will learn more about your dog in
those few short weeks that you may ever learn in the dog's
lifetime. |
|
I use a mix of
all types of learning that dogs are capable of. I think it’s
necessary for most. While some things can be taught with nothing
but positive motivation, there is a time where it is imperative
that your dog learn it MUST comply. An immediate down the moment
you say the word is an example if you let your dog off leash.
Frankly, even if you don’t. Accidents happen and dogs get out.
If they are headed at a run towards a busy road, an immediate
down, especially if they are merrily running TOWARD you, may save
their life. It would be so tragic to have your dog hit because it
was crossing a road to get back to you and didn’t down on the
other side when you commanded it. I don’t feel most dogs do that
well with just positive motivation. It starts there, to be sure.
But proofing the command, in my opinion, often requires
compulsion.
You are correct
that the clicker training is an operant conditioning method. So
is use of food (as either reward or punishment (lack of food)) and
use of a pinch collar. Operant conditioning is a term that
includes most forms of training dogs, including the correction
with a choke collar style. It consists of positive reinforcement,
negative reinforcement, positive punishment, and negative
punishment. Most items (food, clickers, collars, etc.) are
actually used in more than one form.
For example,
clicker training is mainly positive reinforcement but also has an
element of negative punishment (when an incorrect response is .
So if “do the command, get a piece of food.” But food can also be
used in negative punishment as well, where the food is withheld
for the lack of doing the correct behavior. So you say sit, the
dog downs, no food. Negative punishment. Choke collars can be
used in more than one method, also…negative reinforcement (pull up
on collar, as soon as dog sits, release pressure) or positive
punishment (fail to sit, get a jerk on the collar).
For a good
explanation, see this site:
http://www.wagntrain.com/OC/
While I know
that many clicker trainers advocate never using positive
punishment, I do feel it has it’s place, especially in proofing an
exercise that the dog may not care for. However, I do agree that
it is certainly possible to have a highly competitive dog that is
very reliable yet never had any form of positive punishment used.
Nonetheless, I believe that it takes a great deal more time and
effort than many dog owners are willing to invest to get the same
results this way. I do personally use all four methods of operant
conditioning myself. Including the use of a pinch collar in both
negative reinforcement and positive punishment.
I recommend to
others that positive reinforcement is the best way a dog learns.
It’s also much easier to not harm your dog this way. Positive
punishment is something that needs to be applied carefully and in
a way that does not cause physical or mental harm to the dog. I
think many dog owners are perfectly capable of this discernment on
their own, while others need some assistance from a professional
trainer or at least from a friend that is more experienced with
dogs to make sure they are careful both in the nature and timing
of any positive punishment and some types of negative
reinforcement.
|